Short Essay #2
Review the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) and Proposed Rule for the REAL ID Act driving license regulations, and read how the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) reviewed and responded to comments when it published the Final Rule. The DHS broke the comments down into 13 categories in 73 FR 5280-87.
1. Pick one of the 13 categories of comments.
2. Summarize what the comments said and how DHS responded in your own words.
3. Then explain whether or not you think DHS really addressed the comment. Even if you do not think DHS responded in an adequate way, do you think that the rule is defective and subject to court review, or is this an issue where the agency can make its own choice (even if some think that it is not a very good one) without being subject to review?
0 comments:
Post a Comment