1)quotations, references, table, etc. Basically there should be Zero (0) text from the article.
2)specific and to the point. Dont use general linguistic phrases that have no specific meaning related directly to the article.
3)in the Beginning, IN YOUR OWN WORD give precise points that summarize the paper, its research questions and applied theoretical frameworks, and what is the substantive topic of the research, the essential nature of the problem that is addressed in the research.
4)the evaluation should describe which ontological, epidemiological, methodological and human nature stance the paper has adopted. your evaluation should also state if the adopted stances are adequate and suitable or not, and why so.
5)your evaluation should also state how the paper overall is positioned within the "Burrell and Morgan Framework".
6)your evaluation should also state the methods followed by the researchers in that paper: (research Paradigm [Positivist, interpretative] ; view of the world; type of study; nature of explanation; nature of generalization; nature of research subject [tool for intervention, object of study]; approach toward answering the research questions [Inter-subjective, subjective, objective]
7)you should also state how the researchers where involved in the study [ outsider or insider; facilitator or participant; actor or executor]
8)you should mention the evidence formation process [use of questionnaire, independent observation, interviews, focused groups, etc.]
9)you should mention what form of analysis is adopted [single case, multi case, longitudinal, comparative]
10)you should also comment on how convincing is the arguments that is developed in the paper.
11) all that should be included in the first draft of your writing and nothing less
0 comments:
Post a Comment